Fake Gold vs Real Gold: Gold Plated, Gold Filled, Vermeil, and Solid Gold Explained
Not all gold jewelry is solid gold. Gold plated, gold filled, and gold vermeil items contain little to no real gold and have minimal or zero melt value. Learn the differences and how to test what you have.
Solid Gold
Real gold throughout the entire piece. Has actual melt value. Stamped with karat or fineness (916, 750, 585, 22K, 18K, 14K, etc.).
• Has significant melt value
• Karat stamp required by law in most countries
• Does not tarnish or turn green
• Worth recycling and selling for gold value
Gold Plated / Gold Filled
A thin layer of gold over a base metal (brass, copper, steel). Little to no melt value. Stamped with GP, GF, HGE, RGP, or no marking at all.
• Minimal or zero melt value
• May tarnish or discolor skin over time
• Worth very little as scrap
• Cannot be sold as solid gold - illegal misrepresentation
Types of Non-Solid Gold Jewelry
Gold Plated (GP)
None/NegligibleA thin layer of gold (under 0.5 microns) electroplated over a base metal. Very common in costume jewelry.
Common stamps: GP, G.P.
Gold Filled (GF)
Very LowA thicker layer of gold mechanically bonded over a base metal. Better quality than plated but not solid gold.
Common stamps: GF, Gold Filled, 1/20 14K GF
Gold Vermeil
Silver value onlySterling silver (925) coated in gold plating of at least 2.5 microns. Has silver melt value but no gold melt value.
Common stamps: Vermeil
Heavy Gold Electroplate (HGE)
None/NegligibleDespite the 'Heavy' label, this is still electroplated gold. The layer is slightly thicker than GP but still not solid gold.
Common stamps: HGE
Rolled Gold / Rolled Gold Plate (RGP)
Very LowGold sheet mechanically bonded to base metal. More durable than plating but not solid gold.
Common stamps: RGP, Rolled Gold Plate
Gold Tone / Gold Color
NoneNo real gold at all - just a yellow-colored metal or paint. Often found in very cheap costume jewelry.
Common stamps: None (no gold marking)
Watch Out for These Scams
- •Selling gold-plated items as 'gold' without disclosing it is plated
- •Fake hallmarks stamped on plated or filled items to mimic solid gold
- •"Gold tone" or "gold color" items with no precious metal content
- •Misrepresenting 9K or 10K as "high karat" to confuse buyers unfamiliar with purity
- •Online marketplace sellers describing base metal items as "gold" using only color
How to Test Gold at Home and Professionally
Hallmark Check
Look for a karat stamp (22K, 18K, 916, 750, 585) or fineness number on the item.
Limitation: Hallmarks can be faked on counterfeit gold.
Magnet Test
Hold a strong magnet near the gold. Real gold is not magnetic. If it sticks or is attracted, it is likely not solid gold.
Limitation: Many non-gold metals (brass, silver, copper) are also non-magnetic, so passing this test doesn't confirm real gold.
Acid Test
Apply nitric acid to a small scratch on the item. Real gold will not react. Fake metals will bubble or change color.
Limitation: Requires acid kit, slightly destructive, and needs skill to interpret correctly.
Skin Discoloration
Real gold does not react with skin. Green or black staining on skin suggests copper-based alloys. Low-karat gold may also discolor skin.
Limitation: Some people react to even real gold alloys. Not a reliable standalone test.
XRF Spectrometry
A handheld XRF device gives an accurate elemental analysis of the metal without damaging it. Used by professional buyers.
Limitation: Expensive equipment - only available at professional dealers, assay offices, or pawn shops.
Fire Assay
The most accurate method - melts a sample and chemically separates metals. Used for hallmarking and high-value transactions.
Limitation: Destructive - small sample is consumed. Done only by accredited assay offices.
Electronic Tester
Measures electrical conductivity to estimate gold content. Available for home use and professional testing.
Limitation: Less accurate than XRF at lower purities. Can be fooled by some alloys.
Density Test
Gold's density is 19.32 g/cm3. Measure volume (water displacement) and weight, then compare density. Fake metals will differ.
Limitation: Requires careful measurement; hollow jewelry can throw off results.
Fake Gold FAQ
Verify Your Gold
Know what your gold is worth
Once you've confirmed your gold is real, calculate its melt value using our free calculator.
Related Calculators
This is an estimate based on spot price. Actual buyer offers may vary based on market, fees, condition, purity verification, and dealer margin. Not financial advice, tax advice, religious advice, or an official offer to buy or sell precious metals. Always verify with a qualified professional before making important decisions.
On this page
Common Stamps